Motivation,
I believe, is the most difficult thing to teach in the teaching of writing.
When you have such a diversity of students in your classroom, you have to start
getting creative in the ways you motivate them to understand the importance of
rhetoric. Asking them, “Why do you think rhetoric is important to your everyday
life?” is like asking, “When are you going to use the Pythagorean Theorem in
your everyday lives?” The answer will be blank stares, shrugs, and maybe a
cough or two. It’s hard to put things like that into retrospect, and I have to
admit that it was hard to understand things like this as a high schooler. I did
actually say, “What would I ever use this for?” but you slowly begin to realize
that you do need it. That’s why, as
the teacher, you have to provide different outlets and perspectives to the
classroom. And again, it can be a difficult thing to accomplish.
Well,
let’s actually ask the question, “How would you use rhetoric in everyday life?”
Oh, the Ancient Greeks would know. They make the best examples for this
question because they did use it everyday, and we’re talking average citizens
using it. Good rhetoric got you places, and people listened in on it, so you
know that it was something of a big deal. They used it through philosophy,
religion, politics, and bargaining. Well, guess what. So do we, in the modern
age. Let’s all open our eyes to this. We should have activities that
incorporate the real world with the classroom.
I
think we should point out that each field is going to have to use rhetoric in
their lifetime. In actuality, it should be a skill requirement. How many times
does a scientist have to stand in front of a crowd of people and persuade them
that their theory will change the way we think of things? Or an engineer
convincing their customer that their car needs a radiator instead of a battery.
Or a salesman persuading a client that they’re better off with this high-end
microwave than this off-brand one. I’m assuming my point is being made, and if
we’re going to get too redundant, we can throw out there that even politicians
do this during their campaigns, during their speeches, and during whatever they
got to do to keep their followers by their side. In all honesty, rhetoric is
what makes the world go around and if we can get our students to grasp this
concept on the first week of school then we’re doing very well. Or at least if
we can get them to leave on the last day of school with a better understanding
of this skill then I think we can pat ourselves on the back.
To
even begin this we need to start adding more to the mix with the assignments. Prompts
can be an efficient way to handle this. Start the class with a writing
assignment, like have them write a scenario or a dialogue with a client that’s
a difficult challenge to negotiate. Give them an issue that they have to write
a speech on, like a politician. Even observing a speech being performed can
change a perspective; watching or listening to a platform speech can put the
idea that the essay that the student wrote can actually become something.
Anyway you go about it you can always change the experience of the student, you just gotta get creative doing it. So think about it, make a list of interesting ideas for your students, and remember, to use those special rhetorical skills to get your students on the same page as you so that you can have a successful start to your year.
Rachel,
ReplyDeleteGetting students to buy into the course is one of the most difficult tasks we have. If they see no real purpose in learning to write, they won't learn. They'll jump through the hoops and possibly pass the class the first time, and they will promptly forget everything they were supposed to learn about writing. This, of course, is not what we want to happen.
As you suggest, explaining to students, from the first day of the course, that rhetoric is something they will use every day is important; however, I'm not sure that they will buy in simply because we ask them to. I think the solution here has to do with something Dr. Rice had us consider in class. The way to get students to care about rhetoric and writing is to give them writing assignments that coincide with the things they care about and actually use. I am sure you are familiar with the showing vs. telling principle in writing, and I think that applies here. We can tell our students that they will need writing, or we can take it a step further and show them how much they need writing in their everyday lives.
Rachel, I completely agree with you. Motivating students to learn is probably the most difficult part of teaching in any field. However, I don't think that getting students to see writing as a necessary requirement is enough. Sure, that may motivate them to put forth some effort in the course, but I think a long-term solution will be to get students genuinely interested in writing. It's difficult to do this, but I think your approach of being creative with assignments has the most potential to give them genuine writing experiences to explore.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your observation, Rachel. In order to receive quality work from students, it is imperative that they are motivated in their work, and that they remain engaged (if not enthusiastic) with the topics they must write about. I think it is important to stress the importance of rhetoric and to outline a number of things, as you suggest, that illustrate the importance of writing in contemporary society; however, I'm not sure that, as educators, we can make students motivated. I fear that, as much as we may try to incorporate contemporary events and relevant exercises into the classroom, students still will have no desire to engage, aside from the fact that they are required to. Although there are many measures to make learning fun, or enjoyable (to a degree), there is still the issue that, at the end of the day, the learning is, in fact, required of them. There are a number of students who will be more than happy to engage in some new tool/exercise for learning, but there are also students who will resent it because they have no alternative option. Some options that might help these negative learning attitudes could include allowing students to select their own texts to read (from a pre-approved list, of course) and to respond to, allowing students to select their own topics on which to write, or allowing students to design prompts for their peers. I understand how these methods of teaching might have more faults than the more traditional methods, but, with close monitoring, I think that these might be some positive steps to take in order to motivate students.
ReplyDeleteI agree full heartedly that it's impossible to motivate all students that walk through our doors, but the main goal is that we at least try. I feel like if I can just motivate one than I can be quite proud of myself. I'm no where near an expert in teaching nor a motivational speaker, but we can still try.
DeleteYeah, it's going to be tricky, and I'm rather nervous on how this is all going to play out during my first year of teaching, but overall I'm excited for the experience. I can predict that there's going to be a lot of experimenting.
I agree full heartedly that it's impossible to motivate all students that walk through our doors, but the main goal is that we at least try. I feel like if I can just motivate one than I can be quite proud of myself. I'm no where near an expert in teaching nor a motivational speaker, but we can still try.
DeleteYeah, it's going to be tricky, and I'm rather nervous on how this is all going to play out during my first year of teaching, but overall I'm excited for the experience. I can predict that there's going to be a lot of experimenting.
Looks like my last post didn't save, Rachel, sorry. Good thoughts about motivation. It seems to me that's half the battle: getting students motivated to learn, motivated beyond extrinsic values, and capturing their attention when they're most engaged. It's often not just what you teach, but when you teach it.
ReplyDelete